Website SEO audit: the complete method for Swiss SMEs
Before paying CHF 2,000 a month for an SEO retainer, you can audit your own site in 2 hours with free tools and the 10-point checklist we use as a starting point at Voren.
Contents
Why do an SEO audit before signing a retainer
Many SMEs in French-speaking Switzerland blindly sign an SEO retainer of CHF 1,500 to 5,000 a month, for 12 months minimum, with no prior diagnosis. After 6 months, they discover that the agency has spent its time on marginal optimisations while the real problems (Lighthouse at 45, a broken sitemap, no schema.org) remained untouched.
A preliminary SEO audit in 2 hours with free tools lets you:
- Identify the 3 to 5 critical problems before paying for a retainer
- Assess the agency’s competence (“Do you see these problems I have identified? How do you plan to solve them?”)
- Measure the retainer’s effectiveness after 6 months (have the problems identified at the start been solved?)
This 10-point checklist covers the essentials. For a professional audit, Voren delivers a free 30 to 50-page audit in 7 days, and the deliverable is yours to keep, whether or not you sign afterwards.
Point 1: Mobile Lighthouse
To test: https://pagespeed.web.dev/, enter your URL and look at the mobile score.
Healthy threshold: score > 85 Critical threshold: score < 60
If the score is < 60: your site is at a disadvantage on competitive queries. Typical causes: images that are too heavy, render-blocking JavaScript, WordPress plugins piling up. This is the priority, before any effort on content or backlinks.
Point 2: Core Web Vitals in Search Console
To test: Google Search Console → Experience → Core Web Vitals
Healthy threshold: 75% of URLs rated “Good” (green) Critical threshold: < 30% rated “Good”
Search Console gives the figures measured on your real visitors, whereas PageSpeed Insights runs a one-off test. Google uses those figures to rank you.
Point 3: Indexing of key pages
To test: type site:yoursite.com into Google. Compare the number of results with the actual number of pages on your site.
Healthy threshold: 80% of your pages are indexed Critical threshold: < 50%
If too few pages are indexed: a sitemap problem (point 4), an internal linking problem, or a noindex applied by mistake to important pages. Check the “Pages” report in Search Console for the details.
Point 4: XML sitemap
To test: https://yoursite.com/sitemap.xml returns HTTP 200 and has been submitted to Search Console.
Checks:
- The sitemap exists and is publicly accessible
- All your important pages are listed
- No 404 or 301 pages in the sitemap
- If the site is multilingual, hreflang is present
- Submitted to Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools
If there is no sitemap: generate one automatically (the Yoast plugin for WordPress, @astrojs/sitemap for Astro, the next-sitemap plugin for Next.js).
Point 5: Robots.txt
To test: https://yoursite.com/robots.txt
Checks:
- The file exists
- No
Disallow: /line that would block the whole site (a catastrophic error, common after a staging phase) - Sensitive pages are blocked (
/admin/,/wp-admin/, etc.) - The sitemap is referenced:
Sitemap: https://yoursite.com/sitemap.xml
Classic mistake: a site coming out of staging with an uncorrected Disallow: /. Several SMEs in French-speaking Switzerland have lost 6 to 12 months of SEO because of this error alone.
Point 6: Meta titles and meta descriptions
To test: Screaming Frog (free up to 500 URLs) crawls your site and lists all titles and descriptions.
Checks:
- Each page has a unique meta title of 30 to 60 characters
- Each page has a unique meta description of 120 to 160 characters
- No duplicates (two pages with the same title)
- No generic default meta title (“Home · Voren”)
- The main keyword appears in the meta title
Tip: without Screaming Frog, use the Chrome extension “SEO Meta in 1 Click”, which shows the metadata of the current page.
Point 7: H1/H2/H3 structure
To test: on each important page, check the heading hierarchy.
Rules:
- Only 1 H1 per page
- The H1 contains the main keyword
- A consistent hierarchy: H1 > H2 > H3, with no skipped level (H2 straight to H4)
- 4 to 7 H2s per page (for content of 1,000+ words)
Tool: the Chrome extension “HeadingsMap”, which visualises the structure.
Classic mistake: several H1s on the same page (often due to a badly coded WordPress theme). Google no longer knows which hierarchy to follow.
Point 8: Schema.org structured data
To test: https://validator.schema.org/, enter your URL.
Minimum checks:
OrganizationorLocalBusinessschema on the homepageServiceschema on the service pagesArticleschema on blog articlesBreadcrumbListschema on deeper pagesFAQPageschema on pages with an FAQ
2026 bonus: Product / Offer on e-commerce product pages, which enables rich snippets (stars, price, availability) in Google.
Generator tool: merkle.com/schema-markup-generator (free).
Point 9: Backlink profile
To test: Ahrefs Webmaster Tools (free for your own sites), or Ubersuggest, free with limits.
Checks:
- How many distinct referring domains? (DR = Domain Rating)
- Top 10 backlinks (quality or spam?)
- Trend over 12 months (growth or stagnation?)
- Toxic backlinks to disavow?
Healthy thresholds for a Swiss SME:
- New site (< 1 year): 10+ with DR > 30
- Established site (1 to 3 years): 30+ with DR > 30
- Mature site (3+ years): 80+ with DR > 30
If you have < 5 quality backlinks: you are at the start of your SEO. A backlink strategy is the priority (see our dedicated article on the 10 strategies).
Point 10: 12-month organic traffic trend
To test: Google Search Console → Performance → date range: last 12 months.
Checks:
- Is organic traffic growing, stagnating or falling?
- The top 20 keywords you rank for (and their positions)
- Average CTR (< 3% is low)
- Average position (< 30 is healthy, > 50 is a problem)
If there is a continuous decline: a possible Google penalty (Helpful Content Update, Spam Update), a recent technical problem, or lost backlinks. The cause needs investigating.
Prioritised action plan
Once the checklist is done, you have 0 to 10 points to fix, to sort into three priority levels.
Level 1 · SEO blocker (fix immediately)
- Robots.txt blocking everything (Point 5)
- No sitemap, or a broken sitemap (Point 4)
- < 30% of pages indexed (Point 3)
- A manual action visible in Search Console
Level 2 · Major handicap (fix within the month)
- Lighthouse < 60 (Point 1)
- Core Web Vitals < 30% good (Point 2)
- Several H1s per page (Point 7)
Level 3 · Optimisations (to build into the long-term SEO strategy)
- Meta titles/descriptions to enrich (Point 6)
- Schema.org to complete (Point 8)
- Backlinks to acquire (Point 9)
- Content to enrich so that positions improve (Point 10)
Recommended free tools
To do the full audit in 2 hours:
- PageSpeed Insights: https://pagespeed.web.dev (Lighthouse + Core Web Vitals)
- Google Search Console: https://search.google.com/search-console (indexing, performance, errors)
- Screaming Frog: https://www.screamingfrog.co.uk (crawl, meta titles), free < 500 URLs
- Schema Validator: https://validator.schema.org (structured data)
- Ahrefs Webmaster Tools: https://ahrefs.com/webmaster-tools (backlinks), free for your sites
- Ubersuggest: https://neilpatel.com/ubersuggest (overview), free with limits
- Chrome SEO Meta in 1 Click: Chrome extension (quick metadata)
Total cost of the tools: CHF 0.
When to move to a professional audit
This 10-point checklist covers 70% of a professional audit. The missing 30%: in-depth competitor analysis, keyword research with DataForSEO, a semantic content audit, strategic recommendations over 12 to 24 months.
If you identify 3+ critical problems in the checklist, or if you plan to invest CHF 1,500+/month in SEO, a professional audit (30 to 50 pages, delivered in 7 days) is a must.
At Voren, this professional audit is free of charge, and you keep the deliverable even if you do not sign a retainer afterwards. The report makes our case better than any sales pitch, and we work for clients who want to understand what they are paying for.
Going further
If the checklist has revealed problems, or if you want a professional audit:
Request a free SEO audit: delivered in 7 days, a structured 30 to 50-page deliverable.
See our SEO Switzerland package: a retainer with a contractual commitment on execution, never on rankings.
Work out what SEO can bring you: your search volume, your target position and your average order value, in 30 seconds.
See our SEO support: for Lausanne, the canton of Vaud and all of French-speaking Switzerland.